An Arm and a Leg Logo
  • Listen
  • Explore
    • Podcast Episodes
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Starter Packs
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Team
    • Our Impact
    • Our Partners and Supporters
    • Contact Us
  • Support Us

Get the First Aid Kit Newsletter!

Summing up the practical lessons we've learned about surviving the health care system, financially.

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

First Aid Logo
First Aid Kit is a newsletter meant to help you fight a brutal enemy — the American health care system. Subscribe here.

Fun updates: Buying drugs and insurance

You are not alone. Even the smartest experts get socked.
March 16, 2022
 · 
Dan Weissmann
Share
Copy URL

Hey there—

A few experts have weighed in with personal updates on topics we’ve covered here recently: Buying drugs, finding free COVID tests and picking insurance.  

And they find all of this just as hard as the rest of us.

This edition of First Aid Kit is all about finding connections with our fellow humans as we slog through the crap. And sharing an occasional dark laugh, and gaining a couple of new insights.


Buying drugs

Let’s set the mood by pretending we’re talking about a more-fun, more-affordable version of “buying drugs.” If you’ve got 90 seconds, please enjoy this:

https://youtu.be/duGwZSnbLcs

But sadly we’re talking about prescription drugs. Last time I spelled out my best tips, such as they are, for avoiding the worst ripoffs. We dove deep on the games insurance companies and pharma companies play. Bunch of sharks. 

And I immediately heard from Lillian Karabaic about how those sharks are taking big bites out of her wallet with the exact crappy tactics we outlined. 

Lillian is my favorite personal-finance expert. She’s super-smart, and supremely good-hearted — specializing in advice for folks who, like her, have followed their hearts into careers in the arts or non-profits. 

This was her first response to the news that the sharks were coming after her.

If anyone could’ve kept those sharks at bay, it’s Lillian. 

And she’s put up a good fight. After nine hours and 32 minutes of phone calls (she tracked it), she’s got her insurance working on a claims audit. 

She expects to lose, but she’s gonna make them work for it. 

“I’m kind of delaying the inevitable,” she told me. “At least long enough to apply for a credit card that has a decent point sign-up bonus. So I can get something out of this entire situation.”

And she pointed me to a difficulty I hadn’t known about: 

It can be hard to even know if your particular insurance uses the pernicious shark strategy that put her in this position, called a copay accumulator. (I described these in our last installment; they’re bad.)

Lillian worked hard to avoid picking an insurance plan that included this policy…but she couldn’t. 

And it turns out she’s not alone in that. Lillian pointed me to a report from The AIDS Institute, where researchers looked into hundreds of insurance plans, trying to figure out which ones included “copay accumulator” provisions. 

They scoured the internet, then followed up with scores of long phone calls.

“You spend a lot of time trying to ask the right question in the right way so that you get the right person,” said lead researcher Stephanie Hengst. That is, someone who knows what you’re talking about.

Sounds familiar, right? So will their result: Dozens of times, they came up empty. 

However, we got something for their trouble: They made themselves a tip sheet for investigating whether your insurance plan has a copay accumulator, and with their OK, I’ve posted it here. 

Also, we got a darkly-funny An Arm and a Leg episode out of talking with Lillian and Stephanie. 

A photo of a shark with text on top. The text reads filling a prescription means swimming with sharks. Drug company sharks, insurance company sharks. New ep: A rough guide to dangerous waters.

If you give a listen, let us know what you think. Now, on to other disasters… 


Picking insurance

Journalist Libby Watson’s Sick Note newsletter is like First Aid Kit’s super-smart, very-impatient older sibling.

Fuck the band-aids, it says. If you focus on that, you’ll let the assholes off the hook, dummy.

Fair enough. We need a less-horrible system, and we should stay pissed-off enough to fight for it. 

And it’s worth covering the same ground from both angles. 

So: Where we spent three newsletters putting together everything you need to know to have a shot at picking the least-crappy insurance available, Sick Note recently detailed Libby’s savvy, cranky hunt for new insurance of her own. 

Her biggest consideration: Migraine treatments. She’s suffered for years, and recently found something that actually works.

Unfortunately, it’s a super-expensive drug called Vyepti, which isn’t covered by any of the plans she can find. (Libby figures she can fight for a “coverage exception.”)

She’ll also need a specialist willing to prescribe it, and most plans have a very limited number of in-network specialists (like, just one or two). If she ends up with an asshole specialist, that’s a problem too.

Her bottom line, after a lot of research: 

Whatever choice I make feels scary. I have no real way of making a ‘good’ choice; I have a lot of ways of making a bad choice. Even if I make the best available decision, I could get screwed if the plan rejects my request to cover Vyepti, or if the doctor turns out to be an asshole.

She also writes: In the end, she knows she’ll get what she needs.

She’s got a flexible job — so she can sink time into research and haggling — and a lot of know-how. And she can spend a little more if she needs to. 

But it shouldn’t come to this, for me or anyone. Access to doctors and treatments simply should not be determined by how much money you have, or what kind of job you have, or whether you’re good at making decisions about insurance plans.

Hunnert percent agree. A First Aid Kit won’t solve any of those issues. But I hope it can give you the kind of know-how that people like Libby Watson have. 

Wanna go back and watch that High Maintenance trailer now? Seriously, we’ve gotta take care of ourselves.


Getting COVID tests

In January, we looked at how to get COVID tests without paying through the nose.

When we published, one fix was on the horizon: If you bought a rapid test, your insurance — assuming you had insurance — was supposed to reimburse you.

Which sounded inconvenient, at best. And as BuzzFeed reporter Stephanie M. Lee quickly found from her own experience, it could get so much worse.

Now, she’s reported out the full story. 

The good news: This was a glitch — the kind of thing that happens when a giant new policy gets rolled out really quickly, as was the case here. If you were to try to get reimbursed for tests now, you’d probably have a better experience. 

And the broader, better-for-now news is: The omicron peak has passed – though the pandemic isn’t over –  and you can order tests for free directly from the feds. In fact, as Stephanie reports, even if you got tests before, you can order a second round of them; the feds have left-overs.

It’s not everything we want, not by a long shot. But it’s nice to see that even one installment of this newsletter has gone out of date. 


Keep the faith, find the fun

When you live in hell, you’ve got to find the fun. And the compassion, including for yourself. 

My colleague Daisy Rosario introduced me to Jorts the Cat recently. If you haven’t met Jorts, there’s lots more where this tweet came from.

Whenever you’ve got five minutes, please treat yourself to Jorts’s origin story, its sequel and the epilogue. 

You are welcome! 

Until next time, take care of yourself,

Dan 

P.S. It was great to hear from Lillian immediately about our last First Aid Kit. And then we made a podcast about it! 

We also heard from the folks at GoodRx, who we mentioned last time. Turns out (a) they read First Aid Kit, and (b) they have user-friendly information (which we had missed) about patient-assistance programs (from shark drug companies) that can sometimes make super-pricey drugs more affordable. Good to know, and we’ve added it to the web version of our last issue.

If there’s ever something you want us to know, you want to get in touch to say hi, whatever the case – we’d truly love to hear from you.

I write this newsletter, and Gabrielle Healy edits and helps produce it. Reach out to us any time with your thoughts, feedback and questions. 

Get the First Aid Kit Newsletter!

Summing up the practical lessons we've learned about surviving the health-care system, financially.

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

Reporting on why health care costs so freaking much, and what we can maybe do about it.
More about us →
First Aid Logo

First Aid Kit

Get our latest tips for dealing with the healthcare-industrial complex.

July 16, 2026

Mailbag! Getting nickel-and-dimed at your annual

July 2, 2026

Podcast feed drop: A tool everyone needs to hear about

June 26, 2026

New Starter Pack: People being awesome

Subscribe

Have a health care question?

For topic-specific deep dives and recommended reading, start here or use the search bar below to explore our site.

Follow the Podcast

Image

More of our reporting


Starter Packs

Jumping off points: Our best episodes and our best answers to some big questions.

Explore our Starter Packs →

Tell me a story about someone being awesome

It takes skills, patience, and guts to take on the health care system. We could all use a little inspiration.

Help! I’m in collections for medical debt.

So, a debt collector is chasing you over a medical bill. Here's what we've learned about what to do if you're facing debt collection.

How to wipe out your medical bill with charity care

Our guide to an under-the-radar but essential resource for wiping out medical debt.

How do I shop for health insurance?

Picking a health insurance plan can be super confusing. Here's our best advice.

Help! I’m stuck with a gigantic medical bill.

Don't freak out. We've laid out tips to help you manage your medical bills.

See All Our Starter Packs

If you don't know where to start or are just getting to know us, we recommend you start here.
Explore All

Logo for Arm & A Leg

Podcast Episodes

Our show about why health care costs so freaking much, and what we can (maybe) do about it.
Explore the podcast →
July 2, 2026

How to Fight a Health Insurance Denial With a Little-Known Tool (from ProPublica’s Paper Trail)

Remember these words: external review — a powerful and too-little-known insurance appeal.
June 11, 2026

The Prescription Drug Playbook (Full Version)

The best advice we've heard about what to do when you can't afford your meds (from 2025)
May 21, 2026

The Chatbot Will See You Now: Big Tech In Therapy (from Organized Money)

The mental health middlemen selling your data, and one state’s solution (From "Organized Money")
April 27, 2026

The Supreme Court case that could slow generic drugs

The Supreme Court hears a case about "skinny labels" — a legal carveout used by generic drugmakers — that has major stakes for patients.
April 8, 2026

Why drugs cost so much, 101: Medicine monopolies

How a street-smart patent lawyer helped shape a grand bargain between brand-name and generic drug companies — and the unforeseen consequences he's determined to fix.

See the Episode Archive

One of the most enraging, terrifying, depressing parts of American life made entertaining, empowering, and useful.
Explore All

Get the First Aid Kit Newsletter!

Summing up the practical lessons we've learned about surviving the health care system, financially.

Thank you!

You have successfully joined our subscriber list.

Support Us
Contact Us
Follow the Podcast
Image
Find us on Social
  • About Us
  • Listen
  • First Aid Kit Newsletter
  • Starter Packs
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners and Supporters
  • Our Impact
  • Editorial Independence Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
ⓒ 2026 Copyright Public Road Productions
Site by Hafi
Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
  • About Us
  • Listen
  • First Aid Kit Newsletter
  • Starter Packs
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners and Supporters
  • Our Impact
  • Editorial Independence Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Support Us
Manage Cookie Consent

To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Not consenting may adversely affect certain features and functions.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}